← All writing

Criticism · Music

Ranking Taylor's Pop Era

2020 · The five-album Pop period, ranked

Among the many surprises of 2020 was not one but two fabulous T. Swift releases. Or maybe it wasn't that surprising - global lockdown, an artist who is inseparable from her own music narrative (country prodigy pushing the bounds of pop, teenage pop / country artist, full-time NYer / millennial pop (neon sunglasses and all), fuck-it-all rebel who doesn't care what you think, today's unafraid genre-bending, politician-battling and badass CEO of her world) went into isolation like all of us did. Unlike the rest of us, she released (again can't state this enough - while I was sitting on my couch eating cheetos) TWO albums that are the best things she's ever made, in my humble opinion.

In honor of this achievement (with a key assist from CA's latest Shelter-in-Place order), I'm ready to share my current rankings of Taylor's latest five albums, what I'm calling her Pop period. As far as methodology, I gave heaviest weighting to listenability. These rankings will probably change over time. As far as how I came to these rankings - mine is a complex and utterly un-scientific method, some fickle combination of mood, personal experience (lots of fantastic memories jamming T. Swift during late nights with bottles of wine while building endless Ikea furniture, etc), craftsmanship, career arc / narrative, and a healthy dash of the context of our times. I took that entire stew, and applied a standard density formula - the albums with the most bangers ranked higher. Without further adieu:

5) reputation

Don't sleep on this album. From the top, ...Ready For It? announces this is not your standard T. Swift album. This is her Kid A - all synth and base, sass and sway. Gorgeous with its tip-toe rhythm and Getaway Car its soaring, anthemic ballad, both are as apt for the stadium as your favorite foggy drive. King of My Heart makes for a great dance party with the kids - plenty of nights we've spun, endlessly in darkened bedrooms, only a starry nightlight casting blurs across the walls and ceiling. Dancing With Our Hands Tied is more standard T. Swift fare - pure pop, purely enjoyable whenever it comes on.

4) evermore

As this one released just days ago, I'm still processing it. Where I sit now: I'm fascinated by this album. She's in the midst of shedding the past, the previous costumes and personas she'd tried on (as most people in their 20s do). Equal parts elegant and hopeful, she's recently gone through a massive personal evolution with the help of choice collaborators (in this case, her second major release with The National's Aaron Dressner producing). This is the closest she's come to her country roots (most clear in no body, no crime, a twingy two-step number with HAIM). Isolated electric guitar riffs ('tis the damn season, somehow a perfect Christmas song for 2020), finger-picked acoustic (strong opener willow) and isolated piano stripped of all preface (title track evermore, which again proves her indie bona fides when it seamlessly shifts halfway through into a classic Bon Iver tune, complete with yearning Justin Vernon guest appearance) evolve the indie mixtape to its highest form. If you can't find joy in this album, you might not like good music. There's also a deeper form of storyteller Dressner is able to pull out of Queen T. In songs like ivy, she finds a deep personal connection with the subject matter (as far as I can tell, either an homage to Miller Williams' 1997 poem "Compassion," or his daughter Lucinda's fantastic self-released Down Where the Spirit Meets the Bone) when she sings 'It's the Goddamn fight of my life and you started it.' Songs like champagne problems and happiness could be autobiographical, or they could not. I don't know that it matters what we think, and that's a wonderful thing.

3) 1989

I love the narratives around this album. Full-time Big City Girl, fully embraced pop stardom, full-on girl squad with fellow celebrities (musicians, models, and pseudo-aristocracy). Take all that Life, all those experiences, throw in a little Jack Antonoff (from Fun, Bleachers, and Girls' Lena Dunham fame) production, and out comes just a fantastic album. Opener Welcome to New York is all glitz and glamour-packaged excitement of one of the greatest cities in the world. Blank Space in its hollowed-out glory follows; Style is all strut and sauce (and a first dip into the water of potentially alienating her core teen audience with its lusty fervor); Out Of The Woods is a fairly grown-up take-it-or-leave-it perspective on a relationship at the tipping point. That's the top of the album, leading into fairly standard T. Swift All You Had To Do Was Stay and the ubiquitous Shake It Off. Six songs, one helluva kickoff into pop / adulthood. I think the reason I hold 1989 in such high regard is you don't get the beauty and depth of evermore and the gorgeous folklore without it.

2) folklore

Speaking of gorgeous. This is, to me, a perfect album for 2020. Working with Dressner for the first time, Ms. Swift channels all that life and growing up into a quiet, ambitious indie-folk album (a la The National, a la Bon Iver, i.e. serious, heavy-hitter indie rockstar cred - we're only missing a Sufjan drop-in and the indie gods would be universally pleased). Long established as a master storyteller, the strength of this album is in dropping all the curation of her life to date. The freedom she steps into gives us cardigan and an artist with nothing to hide. Just let this wash over you and try not to blush: 'But I knew you Dancin' in your Levi's, Drunk under a streetlight. I knew you, Hand under my sweatshirt, Baby kiss it better.' (And it's not even about her.) Also, look past the source material of the last great american dynasty and find a texture and richness not only sonically but also in the unique way that she can bend a fascinating character study to whatever rhythm and cadence she wants. This is a song that really only Taylor can write, with her ability to turn the entire treatise on 'and then it was bought by me' and examine her own forays into madness, perceived and otherwise. epiphany dives as deep as she as she's ever gone. The stunning harmony punctuated by a little vocal flip following a staircase-descending vocal waterfall and it's already one of the more interesting pieces of music in her catalog. Add in: 'Something med school did not cover, Someone's daughter, someone's mother, Holds your hand through plastic now, 'Doc I think she's crashing out' And some things you just can't speak about.' It's a devastating tribute to our front line workers battling a raging pandemic, and a solemn siren from our times. That's Dylan shit, for real. (Think about it - what is THE great pandemic song* of 2020? The 60s always seem to have multiple artists (musicians, painters, filmmakers, writers) releasing in real-time the soundtrack to the times. All those documentaries and news clips would be set to Creedance, to Dylan, to Jimmy. And what do we have? We have Taylor Fucking Swift staring straight into the devastation and destruction, the corruption and the soft, it's-not-our-fault stances of major tech companies, all the loss and uncertainty we're facing, and takes this swing with epiphany and knocks it out of the fucking park.) (*We do have Kate Tempest, to be fair.) And we haven't even gotten to peace. This song HITS. The nervous tic keeping time, holding a tense challenge against the jazzy bassline. It goes on forever; it's 40 seconds of soft electronic... tapping WAY out of sync with the dueling, smooth-as-fuck bass. When Taylor finally shows, she slides in with confidence, leaning into a melody that can't decide between shakespearean rat-tat-tat and swoon. All this, slung deep in a low, heavy tune. 'All these people think love's for show, But I would die for you in secret, The devil's in the details, but you got a friend in me. Would it be enough if I could never give you peace?' and just slams the breaks to land: 'And you know that I'd, swing with you for the fences, sit with you in the trenches.' It's an entire lifetime in not even half a bridge. IT (as the kids say) SLAPS. GTFO how good this album is.

1) Lover

Take it straight off the top - the best song on a album full of them might just be The Archer. Moody, layered, with a driving beat, Taylor takes it all on - what it's like to be her. And how aware she is of everyone's idea of what it's like to be her. It's self awareness going in circles; it's so hyper aware that every step she takes has a context and a narrative and a meaning, and in the midst of all that swirling self-consciousness (she revealed in 2020's Netflix doc Miss Americana she struggled with an eating disorder at times dealing with all the stress of her life), this queen steps to the mic and DELIVERS All the king's horses, all the king's men. Couldn't put me together again, 'Cause all of my enemies started out friends. She ain't afraid, it's her bloody story. Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince re-envisions her story as the rebel who ran away with the guy. Paper Rings as a pot smoking cheerleader. Cornelia Street, a loner world traveler shyly hitting on a guy in a pub somewhere. Death By A Thousand Cuts is all glimmering lights and a hero taking straight aim at their fears. It's Nice To Have a Friend it's someone who's cool having casual sex, or trying to convince themselves they are. It doesn't matter - it's her story to tell. And don't miss title track Lover, a can't-miss waltz. Yes, there are some average songs on this record. (And one worse, but maybe that's just Me!) But this placement isn't about which album is most advanced (evermore / folklore), the most advancing (reputation), or the most fun (1989). It's the most affecting. Among Ms. Swift's many, many talents has always held at its most base the ability to make you FEEL. Maybe it was hate, maybe awe, judgement, or adoration. Doesn't matter. You likely have felt something about Taylor Swift in your lifetime. And it's finally on 1989 she lets herself feel something - something real, something pure. Have this album on during a rainy jaunt around a city you love and you'll have memories you could carry to your deathbed.