← All writing

Criticism · Television

Reflections on Normal People

On the 2020 series and one perfect music cue

There's a moment in Episode 3 of Normal People (Hulu's 2020 series based on Sally Rooney's novel) - it's a music cue, actually. The series keeps mainly faithful to the source text with minor structural updates (the novel deploys flashbacks in each chapter; the series works mostly chronologically and is well off for it). The end of the third episode is one of the few major variations from the book.

In the scene, Paul Mescal's Connell (equal parts rugged football lad and burgeoning writer struggling to communicate much in real life) has just discovered his friends (and apparently everyone of note) knew about his hidden relationship with Marianne, played with walled-off brilliance by Daisy Edgar-Jones. And as is often true, no one cared. Mescal in a single walking take goes on a journey as the realization sets in. He eventually crumbles to the ground, struggling to bear the weight of realizing he's fucked up something he truly cares about. It's remarkable and painful to watch.

Mescal gets it, and carries it well. The trick in the series, since in the book this reveal takes years, is how to get Connell transitioned out of this incredible moment and (hopefully efficiently) back into the beautiful world of the story. How do we get from the breakdown to the next scene? Well, at some point Mescal lets out this little scream or maybe a kind of grunt. He sort of pulls himself together, and stands back up - no choice but onwards. All of this takes place in maybe 5 seconds.

Then, right on fucking cue: Only You, by Yazoo. It's brilliant. Timeless and hopeful, it marks a convergence of excellent source material elevated by a director and writer who understand the power of less, and an actor capable of translating this journey without any dialogue. (Mescal later carries the achingly beautiful Aftersun with similar clarity.)

The next thing we know, Connell is off at University, in the 'real world' of Dublin, far away from his sleepy coastal town where he and Marianne were once a thing. He's making friends, finding places to live (or the other way around). He's growing up.

This is where the magic of the show happens. It was never about the big, headline-grabbing nudity or intimate sex that drives so much of the story. (They nail the sex, more on this later.) It's about the little moments of life and growth in between. The world around them has gotten bigger, and Connell notices. He seems at once intimidated and opened up by it.

His first introduction into a glimpse of the real world to come is in a classroom. We find him staring off sitting in a large lectinar, slightly dazed, hearing he should be paying attention. Around him is a subtle and tasteful glimpse into classicism and the period of the setting (again, this show savors these tiny moments, so the show is littered with rewarding details like this). Some students have expensive laptops, some tablets. Others pen and paper; Connell not by choice.

The prof is saying they should read as much as they can, as early as they can. Connell looks around the room trying to figure out how seriously to take this vague advice. He's looking for who has answers. (Godspeed, my friend - aren't we all.) We see Connell take this on, and figure out who he wants to be in the world, starting with this decision.

That's just us following Connell around. Then Edgar-Jones returns, reminding us of her magnetism. She lives up to the lush and gorgeous scenery director Lenny Abrahamson paints around her. Whereas Connell is mostly mystery, bound up in his thoughts and internal life, Marianne is out in the world. She touches it, tests it, allows it to bruise her. She's all brimming confidence, maybe some of it put on. But part of her clearly is beginning to understand how central she is to deciding which rules apply to her.

Watch her confidently embrace colleagues, mingle with girlfriends. She doesn't yet know how to wield her physical powers over the world, so she mostly spars intellectually. That said, she's unafraid of physical contact. It's a thrilling proposition as so much of what Marianne begins to learn about the world is through sex. Sex is a way to get over Connell, a way to attract attention, a way to discover herself.

As promised, the sex. It's fabulously intimate, and raw. And there's loads of it. The show savors the buildup and afterglow more than the act itself. We see the awkwardness of will-we or won't-we. We see them sprawled out afterwards, revealing more of themselves than they maybe ever will with anyone else. In the sex, we get to see Connell's deep feminism in his constantly checking in with Marianne - is this okay, are you okay with this? As for Marianne she clearly enjoys the attention, when from Connell and when not. She'll soon enough learn the attention she doesn't want - the show does a fabulous job gently unfolding the prowling threat of an insecure friend who wishes to possess her.

Apparently, they hired an intimacy coordinator to work out the sex on screen. It shows - not a beat is missed that doesn't carry the weight of the story. But the intimacy is more affecting when they have their clothes on. She watches him fall asleep through her laptop. They are constantly making each other tea (seemingly when they don't know what else to do).

Their worlds will intertwine throughout the show (and we're left to assume, the rest of their lives). Connell figures out how to express himself; his journey is one of discovering what to bring out and how. It's an absolute joy of the show to watch him discover his voice amongst his peers, and to stand raptured in front of a painting. Mescal finds all the tiny moments on this journey - in his youth, when he pushes back on his friends for sharing nude photos or talking rude about someone, his voice sort of escapes from him and he seems embarrassed to hear the words aloud. As he grows, he chooses what and when to say what's on his mind. It's very subtle, because he carries a common thread of kindness throughout his playing of Connell, but as confidence replaces embarrassment, we can start to see in the moments after he speaks, he almost doesn't care what his classmates or fellow conversationalists think of his opinion.

Marianne, on the other hand, is trying to figure out what of the world to let in. This is not a character we're used to seeing. She has an idea (seeded in a fucked home life) that she's inherently unlovable, and goes into the world seeking to validate this opinion. She keeps friends and lovers around that submit her to subtle (and overt) forms of cruelty and debasement. She largely knows who she is, but she's maybe always going to struggle to outgrow who her family told her she was. The show captures the subtle threads of the essential her - her evolving style and constant adulting (she's routinely cleaning, hanging the laundry, pulling herself together).

She begins to learn how you can only get to know what people tell you about themselves. Maybe one day she'll also be able to tell someone who she is. It's this big idea that twines all these wonderful details, that she never had to tell Connell. He knew. I don't know that a book or a show need to be about anything bigger than this, but it's a remarkable and worthy journey to watch these two learn how special that was, to find someone who helped them learn who they are.

The thing this show gets so right is how unfair it is to be asked to grow up during these teenage years. Similar to Jason Katim's great Friday Night Lights, this gets right how crazy it is what teenagers and young adults go through. Hormones fuck with their bodies and moods, social structures start to take on more depth and purpose; they start having sex and making huge, life-affecting decisions of who they want to be in the world. It's a lot.

What's worthwhile and beautiful and timeless about Normal People is what it takes away from the typical coming-of-age story, how rare and magical it is to find someone who serves as a mirror, reflecting back the person you could be. That's what Mescal's Connell realizes he's lost for himself at the end of Episode 3. Connell's probably too young to understand how rare it is, his connection with Marianne. It almost doesn't matter. What's real and true is sometimes all of us need to let a little emotion out, and when that's done, pick ourselves up. I know next time when I'm facing a similar moment, I'll be hearing Yazoo's Only You; no choice but onwards.